Butterflies Shouldn’t Remember Being Caterpillars (But They Do)

Butterflies Shouldn’t Remember Being Caterpillars (But They Do)

The Mystery of Insect Metamorphosis and Memory

When a caterpillar undergoes the incredible transformation into a butterfly, it’s like a complete reboot of the insect’s body and brain. The caterpillar quite literally melts into a soupy goo inside the chrysalis, with its cells and tissues breaking down before being rebuilt into the strikingly different adult form. According to our current understanding of neuroscience, this drastic metamorphosis should erase any memories or learned behaviors the caterpillar had prior to pupation.

• Metamorphosis in insects like butterflies and moths involves a complete restructuring of the body, with the larval form dissolving into a nutrient-rich “soup” that is then used to construct the adult.
• The brain and nervous system also undergo a dramatic transformation, with the neural connections that formed memories and learned behaviors in the caterpillar stage being completely dismantled.
• Conventional wisdom in neuroscience suggests that this level of neurological remodeling should result in the adult insect having no recollection of its former life as a caterpillar.

And yet, numerous studies have shown that adult insects can and do retain memories and learned behaviors from their larval stage, even after going through this extreme metamorphosis. This seems to defy our scientific understanding of how memory and the brain work. So what’s going on here? How can butterflies and moths remember being caterpillars when they shouldn’t be able to?.

More: What Causes Bad Breath In The Morning (And What It Could Mean)

The Surprising Evidence for Insect Memory Across Metamorphosis

The idea that insects can retain memories from their larval stage to their adult stage was first demonstrated in a 2008 study on tobacco hornworm moths. In this experiment, researchers were able to train the moth larvae to avoid the smell of ethyl acetate by giving them a mild electric shock whenever they encountered that odor. Remarkably, when those larvae later metamorphosed into adult moths, the adult moths also avoided the smell of ethyl acetate – suggesting they had retained the learned aversion from their caterpillar days.

This finding was quite puzzling, as it contradicted the prevailing scientific view that the complete neural remodeling of the insect brain during metamorphosis should erase any memories or learned behaviors. How could the adult moths remember something their larval selves had learned, when the connections that formed those memories should have been completely dismantled?

Further research has uncovered additional examples of insects retaining memories across metamorphosis:

• A 1994 study found that Drosophila fruit flies could be trained to avoid a specific odor as larvae, and then continued to avoid that odor even after becoming adults.
• Experiments on butterflies have shown that they can remember the location of food sources they learned about as caterpillars, and will return to those same spots as adults.

These studies present a clear challenge to our scientific understanding of how memory and the brain work, at least when it comes to insects that undergo complete metamorphosis. If the insect brain is truly being rebuilt from the ground up, how can any memories or learned behaviors survive that process?

Potential Explanations for Insect Memory Across Metamorphosis

Faced with this mystery, researchers have proposed a few possible explanations for how insects might be able to retain memories despite the dramatic neural remodeling of metamorphosis:

The Chemical Legacy Hypothesis

One idea is that certain chemical cues or “memories” can persist through the metamorphic process and influence the adult insect’s behavior. This is known as the “chemical legacy hypothesis.”

• The theory is that during a critical period of metamorphosis, if the developing adult is exposed to odors or other chemicals that were associated with learning or memories in the larval stage, those associations can carry over into the adult.
• So even though the neural connections are broken down, the adult insect may still respond to the same chemical cues it was exposed to as a larva.

Researchers are generally aware of this potential confounding factor and try to control for it in their experiments. But it’s possible that in some cases, the chemical legacy effect could account for apparent memory retention across metamorphosis.

Differences in Neural Remodeling

Another possibility is that the extent of neural remodeling during metamorphosis may vary depending on the complexity of the insect’s brain.

• The 2023 study that traced neural connections in Drosophila fruit flies found complete dissolution and reconstruction of the memory-related mushroom body neurons.
• However, the authors acknowledged that insects with more complex brains, like moths, butterflies, and beetles, may not undergo such a thorough neural renovation.
• If key memory-related circuits are preserved to a greater degree in these more complex insect brains, it could allow for some memories to survive the metamorphic process.

So the neural remodeling that erases memories in simpler insects like Drosophila may not be as complete in insects with larger, more intricate brains. This could provide a potential explanation for the memory retention observed in studies of moths, butterflies, and other complex holometabolous insects.

Unconventional Memory Storage

A final possibility raised by researchers is that insect memory may not be stored in the same way we typically think of memories being encoded in the brain.

• The authors of the 2023 Drosophila study suggested that memory in metamorphosing insects could work differently than the neuron-to-neuron connections we associate with memory formation.
• Perhaps insect memories are stored or accessed through some other mechanism that is not disrupted by the radical neural remodeling of metamorphosis.

This is highly speculative, as we don’t yet have a clear understanding of what alternative memory storage systems might look like in insects. But it’s an intriguing possibility that warrants further investigation.

The Need for More Research

Ultimately, the ability of insects to retain memories across complete metamorphosis remains a mystery. The conventional neuroscientific view that such memory should be impossible is clearly at odds with the empirical evidence showing that insects can and do remember things from their larval stage.

Resolving this paradox will likely require a deeper, more nuanced understanding of how insect brains and memory systems work – something that the authors of the 2023 Drosophila study acknowledged is still lacking. As they noted, there appears to be a limited number of neuro-entomologists in the world studying these questions.

To get to the bottom of this puzzle, several key areas of research will need to be explored further:

• Examining the neural remodeling process in insects with more complex brains, beyond the relatively simple Drosophila model
• Investigating potential alternative mechanisms for memory storage and retrieval in metamorphosing insects
• Exploring the role of chemical cues and the “chemical legacy” in memory retention across metamorphosis
• Developing new experimental approaches and technologies to better observe and understand insect memory and cognition

As the authors of the 2023 study concluded, the fact that adult insects can remember their larval experiences “gives us something to work toward” in terms of expanding our scientific knowledge. After all, who wants science to be done? The mystery of insect memory across metamorphosis remains an intriguing open question, ripe for further exploration and discovery.

Explore More with Brilliant

If you’re fascinated by the mysteries of insect neuroscience and want to dive deeper, I highly recommend checking out the learning platform Brilliant. Brilliant offers a wide range of interactive, hands-on courses and problem-solving exercises in STEM topics, all created by experts from institutions like MIT, Caltech, and Duke.

“Brilliant is a learning platform made by people who have put a lot of thought and design into being as effective as possible. Everything you interact with on Brilliant was crafted by teachers, researchers, and professionals from MIT, Caltech, Duke, Microsoft, Google, and more. So they know what they’re talking about.”

By signing up through the Brilliant.org/SciShow link, you can get 20% off an annual premium subscription and try out the first 30 days for free. It’s a great way to expand your scientific knowledge and problem-solving skills in an engaging, interactive way.

So if you’re curious to learn more about the inner workings of insect brains, memory, and the mysteries of metamorphosis, be sure to check out Brilliant. Who knows, you might even discover the key to unlocking the secrets of how butterflies remember being caterpillars.